In a Whatnot live auction, a mysterious item labeled as “Pulls 4 to 7 #52” caught the attention of a buyer who went by the username mysterylabs. At the end of the sale, this item sold for $5.00 to the winning bidder. The seller, jjshopper, only hinted at the item’s potential value, stating “Anybody want this fountain service, Coca-Cola?” with a tone that suggested it might be something more interesting.
Chat viewers shared their thoughts on the mystery item, with one speculating that it was a vintage ceramic figurine of Borden’s Elsie the Cow, likely part of a mid-century salt and pepper shaker set. Whatever its origins, the winner seems to have snagged a unique and potentially valuable find. Will we see it reappear in a collector’s showcase, or remain a garage sale mystery?
Check out @jjshopper on Whatnot for more like this.
Love the look? Browse similar finds.
Want in on the next live auction? Join Whatnot and start watching shows like this one.
